As governments around the world grapple with how to protect young people online, one question continues to spark intense debate: how do we verify age on digital platforms without compromising privacy?
Social media, gaming platforms, and online communities have become central parts of modern life. Yet with their rapid growth comes an increasing concern about children’s exposure to harmful content, cyberbullying, and online exploitation. Policymakers, technology companies, and parents are all searching for solutions that balance safety with personal privacy.
The challenge is complex. While stronger safeguards for children are widely supported, the idea of uploading government identification to private platforms raises serious concerns about data security and identity theft.
The Growing Concern Around Online Safety for Children
Digital platforms were not originally designed with robust age verification systems. For years, most platforms simply relied on users entering their birth date during account registration.
In practice, this system has proven ineffective.
Children can easily bypass age restrictions by entering a false date of birth, allowing them access to platforms that were intended for older users. This has raised significant concerns for governments and regulators seeking to create safer online environments for young people.
As a result, policymakers across the world are exploring stronger regulatory frameworks that require platforms to verify users’ ages more effectively.
However, the question remains: what is the safest and most practical way to do it?
The Privacy Dilemma: Uploading Government ID Online
One proposed solution is requiring users to upload government identification such as passports or driver’s licences when creating accounts.
While this approach may appear straightforward, it raises several legitimate concerns.
First, identity theft is already a growing global problem. Many people feel uncomfortable uploading sensitive identification documents to online platforms, particularly those operated by large commercial technology companies.
Second, there is a broader issue of trust. Even if platforms promise strong data protection measures, the idea of private companies storing millions of identity documents in central databases creates understandable hesitation among users.
Many people find themselves in two minds.
On one hand, individuals already share significant personal information online through their everyday use of digital services.
On the other hand, providing official identification to social media companies or online platforms feels like crossing an entirely different line.
Watch the complete Podcast on YouTube.
A New Approach: Age Verification Through App Stores
In response to these concerns, some governments are exploring alternative models for verifying age online.
One example comes from legislation introduced in Utah in the United States in May 2025. Under this approach, responsibility for age verification shifts away from individual apps and towards the major app store providers.
In practical terms, companies such as Apple and Google would act as the verification facilitators.
Instead of uploading identification documents to every individual platform, users would verify their identity once through the app store. Once verified, the app store could confirm whether a user meets the age requirements for specific apps.
This significantly reduces the number of organisations handling sensitive identity data.
How Zero-Knowledge Proof Technology Could Help
One technology gaining attention in this space is known as Zero-Knowledge Proofs.
In simple terms, this technology allows one party to verify information without revealing the underlying data.
For example, a user could provide identification to a trusted verification system. Instead of sharing the actual document with multiple platforms, the system would simply confirm whether the user meets the required age threshold.
The response could be as simple as:
Yes – the user is over 16.
No – the user does not meet the age requirement.
Importantly, the user’s identification details would not be shared with the individual platforms.
This approach could offer a strong balance between privacy protection and regulatory compliance, reducing the risk of personal data being widely distributed across multiple services.
Integrating National Digital Identity Systems
Another potential pathway is integrating age verification systems with existing national digital identity frameworks.
In Australia, for example, systems such as myGov Digital ID could potentially serve as a trusted verification mechanism.
Under such a model, individuals would verify their identity through a government-backed digital ID system. Platforms such as Apple or Google could then receive a simple confirmation that the user meets the relevant age requirement, without ever storing the underlying identification documents.
This approach offers a layered structure of trust.
Government systems handle identity verification, while technology platforms simply receive confirmation signals rather than sensitive personal data.
The Legislative Challenge Ahead
Despite these technological possibilities, implementing age verification laws remains a significant challenge.
Legislation in many jurisdictions requires platforms to take “all reasonable steps” to prevent underage users from accessing restricted services. Determining what constitutes reasonable steps is not always straightforward.
Policymakers must weigh several competing priorities:
- Protecting children from online harm
- Preserving user privacy
- Preventing identity theft
- Ensuring systems are technically feasible
- Maintaining accessibility for legitimate users
Finding the right balance will require ongoing collaboration between governments, technology companies, privacy experts, and the broader community.
Building Safer Digital Communities
Ultimately, protecting young people online is not just a technological or legal challenge it is a societal one.
Parents, educators, policymakers, and technology leaders all play a role in shaping digital environments that are safe, responsible, and respectful of individual privacy.
As the digital landscape continues to evolve, thoughtful conversations and collaborative solutions will be essential in building systems that protect both children and personal freedoms.
Join Us at Our Upcoming Events
Join Us at the National Child & Family Safety Leadership Summit 2026 will bring together leaders, practitioners, policymakers, researchers and community voices from across the country. This important gathering creates space for meaningful dialogue on the most pressing issues impacting children and families including domestic violence, coercive control, child protection, and community wellbeing.
We look forward to welcoming you to this moving and inspiring celebration of women’s achievements and contributions. Don’t miss this opportunity to hear from one of WA’s most influential scientific leaders, Miquela Riley.